top of page
  • Writer's pictureBrenda Heffner

Property Insurance Claims Gone Wrong: Lessons Learned from Common Mistakes

Property insurance provides invaluable protection against unforeseen damages and disasters that can be financially devastating for homeowners and property owners. Whether it's a natural disaster, a fire, theft, or vandalism, having a comprehensive insurance policy can bring peace of mind during times of distress.

However, the claims process can be intricate, and many individuals find themselves navigating through pitfalls that lead to unresolved claims or inadequate compensation.

In this blog, we will explore some of the most common mistakes made during property insurance claims and the valuable lessons we can learn from these experiences.

Failure to Read and Understand the Policy

One of the most significant mistakes homeowners make is neglecting to thoroughly read and comprehend their insurance policy. Insurance policies can be complex and filled with industry-specific jargon, making it challenging for policyholders to grasp the full extent of their coverage. To avoid this mistake, it is essential to sit down with your insurance agent or broker and have them explain the policy in simple terms. Understanding your coverage will help you know what damages are covered, the limits of your coverage, and any exclusions that might apply.

Lesson: Always read your insurance policy carefully and seek clarification from professionals to ensure you fully understand the terms and conditions.

Delaying the Claims Reporting

In the aftermath of a disaster or incident, it is not uncommon for policyholders to delay reporting the claim to their insurance company. Unfortunately, delaying the claims process can lead to complications. Insurance companies usually require prompt notification to assess the damage quickly and begin the claims process. Waiting too long might result in a lack of evidence to support your claim or disputes about the cause of the damage.

Lesson: Report the claim as soon as possible to ensure a smooth and efficient claims process.

Neglecting Proper Documentation

Failing to document the damage properly is a common mistake made during the claims process. Proper documentation is vital in supporting your claim's validity and ensuring you receive adequate compensation. Take photographs and videos of the damaged property, and make a detailed inventory of all affected items. Keep receipts, invoices, and any other relevant documents related to the repairs and replacements.

Lesson: Thoroughly document the damages and expenses related to your claim to strengthen your case and ensure a fair settlement

Underestimating the Value of the Claim

Some policyholders make the mistake of underestimating the value of their claim, either out of fear or because they are unaware of the extent of their coverage. As a result, they might accept settlements that are far less than what they are entitled to, leaving them with a financial burden to bear.

Lesson: Seek professional assistance, such as hiring a public adjuster, to accurately assess the value of your claim and negotiate with the insurance company on your behalf.

Overlooking Additional Living Expenses Coverage

If your property is rendered uninhabitable due to a covered event, most insurance policies offer Additional Living Expenses (ALE) coverage. This coverage helps with the cost of temporary accommodations, meals, and other necessary expenses while your home is being repaired. Many policyholders overlook this coverage, resulting in out-of-pocket expenses they could have claimed.

Lesson: Be aware of the ALE coverage in your policy and make use of it if needed to ease the financial burden during the recovery period.

Making Verbal Agreements

Some policyholders fall into the trap of making verbal agreements with their insurance companies. These informal agreements often lead to misunderstandings or disputes, as there is no written record of what was promised. Always ensure that any agreements or promises made by the insurance company are in writing to avoid confusion and complications.

Lesson: Insist on written confirmation for any agreements or promises made during the claims process.


Property insurance claims can be complex and overwhelming, but understanding and avoiding common mistakes can make the process smoother and more successful. Remember to read and understand your policy, report claims promptly, and thoroughly document damages and expenses. Seek professional help when needed, and make sure to be aware of all the coverage options available to you.

By learning from these common mistakes, homeowners and property owners can navigate the claims process with confidence and receive the full benefits of their insurance coverage when disaster strikes. Protecting your property is not just about having insurance; it's also about being informed and proactive in managing your claims effectively.


bottom of page